Saturday, December 08, 2012

An Improved Star Wars Watching Order: A Modest Proposal

There is a lot of chatter about how to watch Star Wars on the internets. A lot of people talking to folks who have never seen the movies (or who want to rewatch them) wonder about the best way to watch both the new trilogy and the old. Lucas' suggestion (I, II, III, IV, V, VI) is obviously deficient. Some people, for whatever reason, don't like the order of release (IV, V, VI, I, II, III). Some have suggested watching them in a way that goes through the "saga of Vader" between Empire... and Return...: IV, V, I, II, III, VI. The current "winner" of a lot of "geek" suggestions is the "Machete Order": IV, V, II, III, VI. The basic argument is that you get introduced to the idea of Vader-as-father, then go back to the past to see the Vader story unfold, then you see the conclusion of the saga of Vader, but you skip the obviously deficient Episode I.

I suggest an even better order than the Machete Order: IV, V, IV, V, VI. The basic argument is that you get introduced to the idea of Vader-as-father, then go back to the past to see the Vader story unfold, then you see the conclusion of the saga of Vader, but you skip the obviously deficient prequel trilogy. Plus, IV and V are both better than II and III, so this sequence is better at every point.

However, the Machete guy has one criticism of "the release order" that is also going to be true of the Panheresy Order and therefore must be addressed:

Unfortunately, Release Order is also an instant failure, and the reason is a single shot. If you’re watching the original trilogy first, then after the Empire is destroyed and everyone is celebrating, Luke looks over at his mentors, Ben Kenobi and Yoda, and suddenly they are joined by… some random creepy looking teenager who needs a haircut. Placing Hayden Christensen in the ending of Jedi, since he’s not in ANY of the other films, turns an ending that should be celebratory into one that is confusing for the viewer. The fact that Christensen looks like he’s undressing someone with his eyes doesn’t help.
The problem, of course, is that they're using a deficient edition of Return of the Jedi. In the original edition, which I have, there are no digital touchups of anything. Han shoots first and there is no Hayden.

Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Tuesday, November 27, 2012

Ortega y Gasset vs Rove

The Fascist and Syndicalist species were characterized by the first appearance of a type of man who did not care to give reasons or even to be right, but who was simply resolved to impose his opinions. That was the novelty: the right not to be right, not to be reasonable: 'the reason of unreason'.
Compare:
The aide said that guys like me were ''in what we call the reality-based community,'' which he defined as people who ''believe that solutions emerge from your judicious study of discernible reality.'' I nodded and murmured something about enlightenment principles and empiricism. He cut me off. ''That's not the way the world really works anymore,'' he continued. ''We're an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you're studying that reality -- judiciously, as you will -- we'll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that's how things will sort out. We're history's actors . . . and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.''
The aide is popularly-identified as Karl Rove. Note, of course, this is non-partisan, both left and right are identified in Ortega y Gasset, and both sides in America are definitely history's actors.

Wednesday, November 21, 2012

I take it back

I previously commended Dean Chambers of Unskewed Polls for appearing on some news program and admitting both that he was wrong and what he did wrong. But now it seems he thinks he was wrong because of voter fraud instead of, well, just being wrong. He should re-read Nate Silver's book.

In other news, with all of NY and CA counted, it seems that Mittens might end up with... 47% of the nationwide popular vote.

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

The war on Christmas

Black Friday: Buy Nothing Day. I might buy gas and food, I'm traveling. Those don't count.

The first battle in the real war on Christmas is Black Friday. Or, in some stores, it even spills onto Thanksgiving Day now. Never mind that economists have shown that the deals on the whole are not necessarily any better than other times of the year, by the way. I am going to try not to turn this into another tired, anti-consumerist rant. But I am going to float the idea of ceasing to give gifts (or at least radically curtailing the practice). You can take it or leave it, it doesn't really matter to me, but it is worth considering.

I am sure you have heard dozens of people arguing about the consumerism of Christmas, how it detracts from the reason for the season, and what-have-you, so I am not going to rehash those arguments. I'm not even sure who is in the audience here, so I don't know if it is relevant to anybody.

But I think it is relatively uncontroversial to say that "consumerism" is an attack on "Christmas". It is a far more insidious attack than removing a Nativity scene from your community Winter Celebration Display because it is a fundamental attack on how you perceive Christmas, while the latter is just some absurd excision from some crappy art display. Nor is saying "Happy Holidays" a real assault on Christmas: Christmas is the only holiday people actually celebrate at this time of year.

If you are Orthodox or Catholic, you need to be in church on Christmas because that is what the holiday is [1]. Christmas is not about staying in early with your family and opening presents. The perhaps more controversial thing I am going to suggest is that, even if you have children, you do away with presents. We all "know" that Christmas is not about consumerism and that consumerism is part of the war on Christmas. Children often sap our resolve, unfortunately. Why should they, though? You don't need to buy "stuff" to show them you love them, especially not if the cost is teaching them the wrong thing about Christmas. There are millions of non-Christian children in America whose parents don't buy them any gifts in December and they do just fine. Stop participating. They'll be better for it.

Okay, I don't mind a couple small gifts, nor would I ever tell somebody not to give some token out of love that they know will be sincerely appreciated and want to use the opportunity of Christmas to express that love. Nor am I going to say that, if your family needs something specific and you found a good deal on it, you should not purchase it "for Christmas". If people want to talk about what gifts they gave and received on Christmas, I have usually talked about those small tokens which I have often ended up purchasing rather than discussed how Christmas is a religious holiday so we don't usually give gifts, but I might change that.

If everybody followed my advice, it might have "devastating effects" on the American economy. Tough nuts. The status quo is devastating to American consumers and possibly their eternal souls. If you poke around discussions of people in financial trouble on reddit (see /r/personalfinance and /r/frugal), you see dozens of people in rather dire financial positions who think they need to go into $1000 of debt for Christmas just... because. Not so much around this time of year, but at other times of the year, you see people discussing their Christmas debt or planning for their Christmas debt (and it's debt, not expenditure).

One thing I do recommend: Christmas is traditionally a time for almsgiving. Give money toward feeding the hungry, sheltering the homeless, providing medical care for the indigent, and, yes, giving gifts to needy children.

[1] Many types of American Protestant are excused from this responsibility because they, historically, do not believe in Christmas, Easter, or any other feast. The only re-acquired them because the pull of paganism is so strong. Not having any way to actually celebrate the holiday (esp. since they were completely non-liturgical), they will not actually celebrate Christmas as a religious holiday and, if Christmas falls on a Sunday, may cancel their Sunday services. However, these are typically the loudest voices in the matter of the "War on Christmas", which is perceived as taking a creche out of the Winter Festival and saying "Happy Holidays".